Um in Spongebob season 3 episode 3 Just One Bite, Squidward claims he hasnt ever tried a Krabby Patty…but NO!

Season 2 Episode 1 Untied Shoes, Squidward eats multiple Krabby Patties when Spongebob flings them into his mouth when he trips over his untied shoes in the kitchen.

I feel betrayed and lied to